Exciting News! Trivium welcomes Paradigm Financial Partners and Lyons & Lyons, CPAs.

Why Do I Owe Taxes on my RSUs if I Haven’t Sold Them?

by | Mar 9, 2022 | Business

Two People Discussing

Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) are a form of equity compensation that give you ownership in the company you work for, either to augment a base salary or as a bonus. Unlike regular stock options, which require putting money down to exercise them, RSUs are typically owned outright by the recipients once they vest. After the RSUs meet the vesting requirements—which can be immediate or set to a schedule—you are free to do what you want with them, including hold, sell, or gift them.

While RSUs aren’t terribly complicated from a tax perspective, they can cause a lot of confusion because IRS withholding rules are different on RSUs than they are on regular income.

How are RSUs Taxed?

Because RSUs are considered supplementary income by the IRS, your employer is only required to withhold 22% on earnings up to $1 million (versus the previous 25% before the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act was passed). Essentially, this means that if you are compensated with RSUs and you earn under $1 million your employer will likely only send 22% of the RSU value to the IRS to cover the taxes you owe. The employer usually does this by selling shares of your RSUs on the date they vest.

The Problem: Not Enough is Withheld

The problem is that RSUs are taxed as ordinary income. That is, they will be taxed at your income tax bracket. So, unless your income (including salary, bonuses, and other forms of executive compensation) is less than $86,375 as a single individual (or $172,750 as a married filer or $86,350 as head of household), you will owe more money on your taxes than the 22% that was withheld by your employer. In most cases, people earn more than the 22% tax bracket and find themselves underwithheld.

The more money you make, the greater impact this will have on your tax bill.

  1. For individuals in the highest tax brackets, this can result in an underpayment of as much as 15% of the value you earn in RSUs in federal taxes in addition to state taxes.
  2. If the IRS deems you haven’t paid enough throughout the year, you can be charged penalties for underwithholding.
  3. If your stock is quickly increasing in price, any of your newly vested shares will be taxed at the price at which they vest.

So How Do You Avoid Being Underwithheld?

One option is to request more taxes be withheld when the RSUs vest. Another is to sell enough units to cover the taxes withheld as well as the additional income taxes.

Option 1: Adjust Your Withholding

Adjust your withholdings to the highest tax bracket that your pre-RSU compensation will reach. If you’re in between tax brackets, you can either withhold more and receive a refund if it is too high; or, withhold at the lower bracket if you prefer to keep more money in your pocket now and pay the difference later.

Option 2: Sell RSUs as They Vest.

This strategy involves selling enough units to cover the taxes withheld as well as the additional income taxes. Lay out a schedule at least a year in advance to sell your RSUs as they vest. Keep in mind, selling RSUs does not create the tax burden unless the price of the stock has changed since the shares first vested. If your RSU prices changed from when they first vested, you may owe additional taxes.

Selling your RSUs as they vest is the most conservative approach to handling this form of compensation, but being tax-aware and tax-prepared will be critical in keeping as much of your earnings as you can.

Ask Your Money Team: Which Strategy is Right for Me?

If you expect to continue to receive RSUs, the best course of action is to develop a tax strategy that doesn’t put you in a precarious position as your RSUs vest. No one likes a tax surprise, especially to the tune of an extra 15+%!

If you are a business owner in need of a tax plan that takes into account your various forms of executive compensation, the advisors at Trivium Point are only a phone call away.

We serve clients locally in the greater New York area and virtually across the country. Contact us today to schedule a complimentary consultation call to discuss your opportunities.

*The LPL Financial registered representatives associated with this website may discuss and/or transact business only with residents of the states in which they are properly registered or licensed. No offers may be made or accepted from any resident of any other state.

Securities and Advisory services offered through LPL Financial, a Registered Investment Advisor, Member FINRA/SIPC.. Trivium Point Advisory and LPL Financial are separate entities. Tax and accounting related services offered through Trivium Point Advisory LLC, DBA Trivium Point Advisory, LLC. Trivium Point Advisory is a separate legal entity and not affiliated with LPL Financial. 

The opinions voiced in this material are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. This information is not intended to be a substitute for individualized tax or legal advice. Please consult your legal advisor regarding your specific situation. LPL Financial Representatives offer access to Trust Services through The Private Trust Company N.A., an affiliate of LPL Financial.

LPL Financial does not offer tax or legal advice or services

The opinions expressed in this material do not necessarily reflect the views of LPL Financial.

This article was prepared by Lexicon Advisor Marketing. This article was prepared for Trivium Point Advisory’s use.

Connect with Trivium

Trivium Point Advisory

What’s the next step for your business?
Take our fast business health assessment to find out!


Related Articles

Maximizing Profitable Exits: How to Price a Business for Sale

Maximizing Profitable Exits: How to Price a Business for Sale

Selling your business is a significant milestone. After years of hard work and dedication, it’s time to close this chapter and move on to the next. But how do you price a business for sale? And what factors can you control to influence the final…

How to Convert Your LLC to an S Corp

How to Convert Your LLC to an S Corp

Your LLC is thriving, with consistent profit growth over time, yet your self-employment tax bill seems to follow suit. It’s time to reevaluate your business structure and possibly make a transition. Could shifting from LLC to S corp be the answer?